PDA

View Full Version : Exercise craze that crippled a generation



Nick1974
03-16-2007, 12:24 PM
An interesting article from this week's UK's "Times" newspapers.


http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article1494937.ece



Exercise craze that crippled a generation...

They were promised the body beautiful and their mantra was “No pain no gain”. Two decades later they are feeling it again — in their knees, hips and lower backs. They are the casualties of the aerobics boom.

The craze began in the late 1970s but it was the actress Jane Fonda who really got people moving. Following her lead, thousands climbed into Spandex, donned headbands and twisted and punched the air in church halls across Britain.

Now they are more likely to be seen in physiotherapy. Nicki de Lyon, of Sports and Spinal Clinics, London, said: “They have knee and hip and lower back problems. It was not just the constant impact on hard floors, which put pressure on joints, but the twisting movements. And in the 1980s there had not been any research into the right footwear.”

The fitness industry was in its infancy. Robin Gargrave, of the YMCA, said: “People didn’t know what they were doing. They were just following America. Now we know that jogging on the spot waving your arms in the air isn’t the best thing for your body.”

Derrick Evans, who went on to become Mr Motivator, visited a leisure centre in Harrow in 1981 and saw hundreds of women doing “Popmobility”. He hired the two women leading them and set up a class at a church hall in Neasden.

“After a few months I decided I could do this,” he said. Before long he had become the presenter Gloria Hunniford’s trainer and was motivating millions of viewers on This Morning. “In those days it wasn’t critical to have qualifications. There weren’t really any around.” Now 54, he claims to be “fitter than a fiddle” — but his routines were always “moderate”. Others were less so. Andy Jackson, of the Fitness Industry Authority, says that, in the first flush of the craze, “a lot of deconditioned people suddenly started exercising with the intensity of Linford Christie”.

Disciples were told that pain was good for them. “It’s positive pain, just like childbirth,” devotees in America shouted. As the craze took off in Britain, Geri Livingston bought a cat-suit and joined an energetic group in a church hall in Cheshire. All through the 1980s she sought out the toughest classes, attending up to four a week. “My knees just kill me now,” said Mrs Livingston, now 44. “I can’t jog any more, and I have lower back problems.”

Hardest hit were the instructors. “I would be taking 20 classes a week,” said Ebony Williams, who now teaches Pilates. “My knees are painful and swollen, I’m seeing a chiropractor for my back, and I have to have regular massages. All the instructors I knew have had the same problems with their knees, back, joints and shoulders.”

Aerobics is now in decline. In Britain it has been supplanted by a bewildering array of low-impact routines and “conditioning” programmes aimed at people in their mid50s. There, in softly lit studios, next to Japanese fountains and no longer wearing Spandex, the walking wounded of the aerobics boom may seek to soothe their battered bones.

Coach Jones
03-16-2007, 12:40 PM
Nick, nice article, though I would have to disagree that the aerobics of old have been replaced with more healthy approches. We're still in the throws of the no pain - no gain mentality.

People are routinely put through workouts such as (some of my raging pet peeves)

Cardio Kickboxing, Cardio Boxing, etc that include movements that are not potentially harmful if not done correctly - but harmful. They are asked to take their bodies through movements they have no concept of and perform them at a pace fit for a racehorse. A finer recipe for injury has never been created.

The beauty of applying RMAX methodology is that you can get the same results...BETTER results and do so in a health-first manner. The longer you can stay in the game...the better you'll be at it.

Oh and Nick...

Please fix your signature to show your full name.

Thanks.

Coach Gostnell
03-16-2007, 01:39 PM
Way back when I worked in a nut house (literally, we packed & shipped nuts - I guess you could say I was a Bag Lady), we decided to get aerobic & did Fonda's workout along with the tape before the workday started, but at the second viewing, we all hated her video persona so much, we never did it again. Lucky us it turns out!

When I bought the first Warrior Wellness video tape, I was worried the same "presenter burnout" effect might happen. Instead, years later I was still grinning at some of Coach Sonnon's remarks though I'd heard 'em hundreds of times before. Still makes me smile to think of "Don't do it in front of a window..." :)

James Boelter
03-16-2007, 06:58 PM
I said something like this when I reviewed Dr. Bob Arnot's book "Wear and Tear" on Amazon, which was the sequel to his book "Turning Back the Clock", which advocated high powered aerobic and endurance exercise and heavy duty weight lifting as the road to health and wellness. (To be fair, there was also some mention of better nutrition) I semi-jokingly suggested that the real title of "Wear And Tear" should be "Turning Back the Clock II - The Retraction."

Here's the review, if anyone cares to read it. I try to keep the snark to a minimum, honest.

http://www.amazon.com/Wear-Tear-Stop-Pain-Spring/dp/0743225562/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/102-3914410-6659312?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1174096420&sr=8-1

Soheil John Ward
03-17-2007, 05:35 PM
Another factor could be the whole pack mentality with the sadomasochistic bent vs. our intuitive training approach. Where people are encouraged to find flow vs pushing through pain at someone else’s pace.

A comparison in sport would be the careers of athletes. It seems to me that the careers of most team sport athletes are shorter than the careers of athletes in individual sports. I think this comes from the pressure to play injured or push past the pain for the benefit of the team. This is a noble human trait, to sacrifice for others, but it can become distorted and sick when we sacrifice our health to please others.

I'm not saying either aerobics or sports are bad things. I just think we have to look at the culture that led to those injuries. People need to learn to listen to their bodies and then they will be able to take responsibility for their health and wellness. CST is the best system that I know of for doing that.

I haven't read Dr Arnot's book, but "high powered aerobic and endurance exercise and heavy duty weight lifting as the road to health and wellness" doesn't seem incompatible with CST. Try the 4x7 program!

KD Jones
03-18-2007, 05:39 PM
... people are encouraged to find flow vs pushing through pain at someone else’s pace.
(...)
I think this comes from the pressure to play injured or push past the pain for the benefit of the team. This is a noble human trait, to sacrifice for others, but it can become distorted and sick when we sacrifice our health to please others.

Dead on. The majority of my life, my belief was "victory goes to the most afflicted." Ended up with me (and some others) watching victory heading off somewhere else entirely with someone more sensible and well-balanced.

And James, I really liked this, from your Amazon review:
"His candid descriptions of his own joint and health problems are obviously a direct result of all the running, biking and cross country exteme events he did in the previous book - although he never actually admits the connection. If you are paying attention, this tends to damage his credibility as an expert - he was 100% sure about his methods in his last book, but now he's hurting and achy, so now he's 100% sure about his new methods. Indian yoga masters and Chinese Tai Chi masters and Pilates instructors and even physical therapists around the country would laugh at him until their sides hurt."

I've found it necessary to be pretty forgiving of people's mistakes and errors in judegement... even if they affect others... IF they have acted responsibly and in good conscience given the best information available to them, and with their true best efforts. Still, when a person is attempting to have an effect on other's health (meaning, their LIVES) I would expect them to start with a very broad radar, both internal and external, very closely read.

And even then, once burned, I'd be more than twice shy...