rbibbs
04-30-2004, 07:24 PM
I'm old, scrawny, and skeptical... even in 'new products' from established vendors. Clubbells... I expected some improvement in power-range and coordination but that's about it.
A brief history of time (with Stephen Hawking's indulgence, I hope): I'm 5'11 140# and been that exact size since 1962. I first picked up a Clubbell in late December 2003. I could do a few reps of most everything (except squats, troublesome knees) with 10s. 15s were too hard to hold on to, even to swing, without the added traction and choke of gripping the urethane (bad form). So I bought 10s in late January and play with them intermittently. Not "hardcore" training... I have to admit, I don't have the hormones for that any more... recovery takes way too long. Just casual use, what I felt like doing, in between days I train BJJ.
Zoom to present. I'm still skeptical (engineer, can't help it). I have to see readily-quantifiable evidence of improvement in performance before I believe it.
A datapoint: 3 months ago (when I got my 10s), I couldn't hold on to 15s, much less retrieve one from behind-the-shoulder position. This also tells us that it would have been utterly impossible to tricep-curl a 10 from that position (using brute-force instead of biomechanical form). I proved this to myself by trying occasionally.
Thursday, I had the opportunity to demonstrate Clubbells to a much larger, younger guy-- 6'5 230. Sure, 10s are too light for him. To determine that for sure, I had him tricep-curl the tool from behind his shoulder, and he could. In the course of demonstrating that... so could I!
Readily-quantifiable evidence. I think I just sold myself at least one 15.
A brief history of time (with Stephen Hawking's indulgence, I hope): I'm 5'11 140# and been that exact size since 1962. I first picked up a Clubbell in late December 2003. I could do a few reps of most everything (except squats, troublesome knees) with 10s. 15s were too hard to hold on to, even to swing, without the added traction and choke of gripping the urethane (bad form). So I bought 10s in late January and play with them intermittently. Not "hardcore" training... I have to admit, I don't have the hormones for that any more... recovery takes way too long. Just casual use, what I felt like doing, in between days I train BJJ.
Zoom to present. I'm still skeptical (engineer, can't help it). I have to see readily-quantifiable evidence of improvement in performance before I believe it.
A datapoint: 3 months ago (when I got my 10s), I couldn't hold on to 15s, much less retrieve one from behind-the-shoulder position. This also tells us that it would have been utterly impossible to tricep-curl a 10 from that position (using brute-force instead of biomechanical form). I proved this to myself by trying occasionally.
Thursday, I had the opportunity to demonstrate Clubbells to a much larger, younger guy-- 6'5 230. Sure, 10s are too light for him. To determine that for sure, I had him tricep-curl the tool from behind his shoulder, and he could. In the course of demonstrating that... so could I!
Readily-quantifiable evidence. I think I just sold myself at least one 15.